When is Easter Anyway?


Easter date worksheet

In January, I have posted my investigation of the difference between the dates of Christmas celebration in western and eastern Christianity.  If you think, that was confusing, hold on.

The short answer to the question “when is Easter?” is straightforward.

Easter Sunday is the first Sunday after the first full moon on or after vernal equinox. — www.timeanddate.com

This has to do with the Jewish Passover holiday which is based on the Hebrew moon calendar.

Let’s use this definition.  The equinox is on March 20th.  It’s an astronomical event with a fixed (or almost fixed) date.  The next full moon after March 20th in 2015 is on Saturday, April 4th.  Therefore, in 2015, the Easter Sunday is on April 5th.  Easy.  Right?  Why then Eastern Orthodox Christians celebrate Easter on Sunday, April 12th in 2015?

It was an interesting quest for me to figure this out.  As I mentioned in my post about Christmas dates, Eastern Orthodox Church uses Julian calendar for its celebrations.  Gregorian calendar is 13 days ahead of the Julian calendar (at least, until 2099).   My first thought was that Julian equinox is 13 days after the Gregorian equinox, on April 2.  But that’s not true.  In Julian calendar, the date of equinox is set to March 25th which is April 7th in Gregorian calendar.  Then I thought, to get the Orthodox Easter date, I need to find the full moon date after April 7th which is May 3rd, 2015.  Apparently, that doesn’t work because Orthodox Easter is on April 12th in 2015.  What’s wrong?

It turns out that the Orthodox Church uses ecclesiastical full moon to calculate the Easter date, not the astronomical full moon.  Ecclesiastical full moon used to determine the Easter date is called paschal full moon.  The paschal full moon is calculated based on golden number:

Golden Number = (year mod 19)+1 — www.webexhibits.org

The number 19 has to do with Metonic cycle: the dates of Lunar phases repeat every 19 years.  The Julian date for the paschal moon is simply tabulated.  It turns out, the equinox date is not used for this calculation at all (or, rather, the equinox date is accounted for in the table).

Golden number Full moon Golden number Full moon Golden number Full moon
1 5-Apr 8 18-Apr 15 1-Apr
2 25-Mar 9 7-Apr 16 21-Mar
3 13-Apr 10 27-Mar 17 9-Apr
4 2-Apr 11 15-Apr 18 29-Mar
5 22-Mar 12 4-Apr 19 17-Apr
6 10-Apr 13 24-Mar
7 30-Mar 14 12-Apr

www.webexhibits.org

Let’s try this for 2015.  2015 modulo 19 = 1.  In 2015, golden number is 2.  Julian paschal moon date is March 25th, which is April 7th in Gregorian calendar, and the first Sunday after April 7th is April 12th.  As you see, the paschal moon date April 7th calculated using the golden number table is 3 days after the astronomical full moon on April 4th.

For 2016: Golden number is 3, Julian paschal moon date is April 13th, which is April 26th in Gregorian calendar, and the first Sunday after April 26th 2016 is May 1st 2016 which is correct.

In 2016, Orthodox Easter is more than a month after the western Easter which is on March 27, 2016.  Let’s check this, by the way. Full moon after March 20, 2016 is Wednesday, March 23rd, 2016, so, first Sunday after that is March 27, 2016.  Good.

In 2014, Orthodox and western Easter dates both fall on April 20th.  Let’s check again.

Orthodox: golden number is 2014  modulo 19 = 0.  Golden number is 1.  Julian paschal moon date is April 5th, 2014 which is Friday, April 18th, 2014 in Gregorian calendar.  The Sunday after that is April 20th.  Western: full moon after March 20, 2014 is Tuesday, April 15th, 2014, and the first Sunday after that is, again, April 20th.

Finally, it seems that I got it right.  I think, it’s easier than the tax return, after all.

For the geeks, here is the “full monty”: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computus

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “When is Easter Anyway?

  1. Pick a date, any date. It was all about co-opting the pagan holidays that celebrated the winter solstice and the spring equinox, anyway. We know that Christ wasn’t born on December 25th and he possibly wasn’t crucified coincident with the first full moon after the spring equinox. That’s why different religions, even different Christian religions, celebrate Christmas and Easter at different times. So seriously, who cares?

    • Well, you may say “who cares?” if you are not interested. Some people pay millions for a single baseball card signed by some player 50 years ago. I have no interest in baseball history, so to me it would sound strange to pay so much money for a piece of paper. Human passions are irrational. I find it very fascinating how myths, traditions, and science used several thousand years ago are interwoven in one holiday. Just to figure out the date of the holiday, I had to learn about Hebrew lunar calendars, moon phases, equinoxes, Roman calendars and the history of its later corrections. It’s also interesting how Easter blends Hebrew Passover holiday carrying connotations of social justice and freedom from oppression with the pagan spring and fertility celebrations, beginning with the name of the holiday:

      Old English ēastre ; of Germanic origin and related to German Ostern and east. According to Bede the word is derived from Ēastre, the name of a goddess associated with spring.

      which has pagan origins and ending with such attributes as bunnies and eggs, fertility symbols. But I totally understand if someone says “who cares?”

      • Perhaps “who cares” came across as too callous. What I was trying to express is that religions borrow heavily on each other and on pagan rites. So it seems that the dates chosen to celebrate these religious holidays have less to do with the events that they are supposed to be celebrating than with what appeals most to the flocks and generates the most converts.

        • I think, you are right. Religions survive by gaining followers. “Be fruitful and multiply” is the ultimate survival law for living things and ideas. It’s not a coincidence that the most popular religions focus heavily on proselytism and regulating sex life to promote procreation (abortion and contraception bans, bans on sex during periods, bans on incest, etc.) In this race for survival, the winner is not the most logical or the most “moral” idea. The winner is whoever gains the most followers with whatever means. Ironically, religions are subject to the same “survival of the fittest” law that some of them deny. This also applies to atheism or any other belief system. It’s neither good nor bad. It’s just the way things are – a factual observation. People may like it or not.

  2. I think I read somewhere that, due to various orbital mechanics, the actual vernal equinox can vary between March 20 and 23 (Gregorian), but that for purposes of Easter calculation, it was set to March 21.

    The whole process seems beset with arbitrariness. I used to wonder why no one simplified it to something like the last Sunday in March. (Apparently some states have done something like that simplification for Spring Break.) It seems that Christians gave up trying to stay in synch with Passover centuries ago, but not with having some relation to the Jewish lunar calendar. Now that the whole thing can be done with software, I guess it will never be simplified.

    • There have been attempts to reform the date of Easter, but, I guess, it’s OK as is for everyone involved.

      http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Easter#Reform_of_the_date

      There is a table listing the dates of the spring full moon, astronomical Easter, Gregorian Easter, Julian Easter, and the Passover. It appears that Gregorian Easter does not always coincide with astronomical Easter (first Sunday after the full moon following the vernal equinox). E.g. 2019. Not sure why. Most likely, the fluctuation of the equinox date that you mention is the reason.

Feel free to leave your comments and sarcastic remarks

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s